Jay McLelland

Being born and raised in stunning Niagara, Jay has a vast insight into the region and the people.  His enthusiasm for the area will excite newcomers and inspire locals to see the area with a fresh perspective.  Jay is rooted in his community with a solid network of people he’s known for years and thrives on meeting new people and growing new relationships.    

Since earning his license in 2018, Jay has become a top performer in his new-found career. His ability to communicate effectively and with an air of calmness puts his clients instantly at ease and brings a smoothness to each transaction. 

With each client experience, Jay brings a personalized approach by understanding his clients and their home needs.  Adding a special touch to each home, Jay ensures that his clients are represented in the quality and value of each home purchased or sold. He will extend to his clients the care and individual attention they deserve.

When you meet Real Estate Agent Jay McLelland, you will soon realize you have made a friend.

Our Brokerage Listings

Search/Filter Properties


For sale $379,900

276 Oakdale Avenue Unit# 105

St. Catharines

2 Bedroom 1 Bathroom 890 sq. ft
For sale $1,149,000

7 Camelot Court

St. Catharines

4 Bedroom 4 Bathroom 1917 sq. ft
For sale OPEN HOUSE $599,900

153 Province Street N


4 Bedroom 2 Bathroom 1400 sq. ft
For rent $2,200 Monthly

24 Prestwick Avenue

St. Catharines

4 Bedroom 2 Bathroom 700 sq. ft
For sale $638,000

1 Beatrice Street

St. Catharines

4 Bedroom 2 Bathroom 925 sq. ft
For sale $465,000

81 Scott Street Unit# 812

St. Catharines

2 Bedroom 1 Bathroom 900 sq. ft
For sale $1,230,000

99 Loretta Drive


4 Bedroom 2 Bathroom 1898 sq. ft
For sale $1,349,999

9812 Green Road

Caistor Centre

4 Bedroom 3 Bathroom 2868 sq. ft
For sale OPEN HOUSE $989,000

8 Donalda Court

St. Catharines

4 Bedroom 3 Bathroom 2678 sq. ft
For sale $1,449,000

10252 Willoughby Drive

Niagara Falls

3 Bedroom 4 Bathroom 4025 sq. ft
For sale $2,298,000
For sale $577,777

15 Towering Heights Boulevard Unit# 1204

St. Catharines

3 Bedroom 1 Bathroom 1204 sq. ft
For sale $679,900

280 Rosewood Avenue

Fort Erie

3 Bedroom 2 Bathroom 1925 sq. ft
For sale $965,000

20 Pioneer Court

St. Catharines

3 Bedroom 3 Bathroom 2627 sq. ft
For sale $549,900

62 Louisa Street

St. Catharines

3 Bedroom 1 Bathroom 1100 sq. ft
For lease $12.25 / ft2

145 King Street Unit# 2

St. Catharines

1400 sq. ft
For sale $545,500

3998 Victoria Avenue Unit# 407


2 Bedroom 1 Bathroom 990 sq. ft
For sale $474,900

5936 Delaware Street

Niagara Falls

3 Bedroom 2 Bathroom 2500 sq. ft
For sale OPEN HOUSE $559,900

3 Cleveland Street


3 Bedroom 1 Bathroom 1100 sq. ft
For sale $569,900

32 Chapel Street S


3 Bedroom 3 Bathroom 2300 sq. ft
For sale $569,900

32 Chapel Street S


2 Bedroom 1 Bathroom 2400 sq. ft
For sale $599,900

7370 Monastery Drive Unit# 1

Niagara Falls

2 Bedroom 2 Bathroom 1080 sq. ft
For sale $1,098,000

66 Courtleigh Road

St. Catharines

4 Bedroom 3 Bathroom 1790 sq. ft
For sale $980,000

25 Wilfrid Laurier Crescent

St. Catharines

4 Bedroom 3 Bathroom 1939 sq. ft

Jay McLelland Reviews & Testimonials

My Husband and I would like to personally thank Jay for his professionalism, Knowledge, and Friendship over the past several months. Jay worked tirelessly on selling our property with showing after showing.  He communicated with us on every step in the process, we never wondered how hard he was working – WE KNEW! We had a few hiccups along the way in selling and buying our new property, but he was calm and very patience with us. If it wasn’t for Jay we would have walked away from our new home, Jay saved the day and the deal. He is and will be a Realtor that we will recommend to anyone looking and forever will be our Realtor 😊 Thanks again Jay for everything.

C & S

My Brother and l sold our Mother’s house with Jay McLelland. From start to finish we were provided with the best experience possible. Jay is very knowledgeable, professional and friendly to deal with. Jay helped us with a handyman to fix up the house. Fantastically saved us with a new lawyer and miraculously we finalized probate in one week to close the deal!!!! This was my first time selling a house and Jay was so patient with all my questions and concerns. I would highly recommend Jay and will use him again in the future.

Christine R

Jay far exceeded any expectations that I had when looking into selling my home. He was amazing from start to finish, answering any questions that I had, and sharing his expertise to ensure that my needs were always met. He staged my home beautifully with pieces right out of his own collection, helped with lawn care during the selling process, and even got his own subcontractors to come in to paint, and fix a plumbing issue prior to listing. The headaches that he alleviated, and the finesse that he exuded being a multi faceted Real Estate Broker, was evident in the success of my home sale, and also in his many months of being Top Producing Broker in his firm. He was always approachable, humble, communicative and so hardworking and I couldn’t recommend a better Realtor®. Thanks for all your hard work and dedication in this listing Jay!”


We sold our house and purchased a house with Jay. He gave us professional advice and when we needed help, he was always there. He made my house attractive and sold it at a good price, it took only 5 days. 

We were buying a house in Mississauga, he showed EVERY house we wanted to check. And specially thanks to him because we had a really hard time to get a big mortgage, he helped us with his connections and made us get a nice deal. 

 We are very impressed on his dedication. He also arranged contractors for us to repair and house upgrade, as well as lawyer. All of those people are reliable and we were very satisfied.

 He always answered quickly when I ask questions. He was always kind and friendly. He was always on time and never made us wait. 

 I want to give him 6 stars if I can. I would definitely  recommend him to all of my friends and I will return when I buy next house for sure. Thanks Jay!!!

James & Jane Jo

Jay recently sold our family home at a time that was neither envied nor recommended. The time we chose to sell was in itself a challenge, with covid restrictions everywhere, people not working, financial institutions not lending, etc. Jay came up with a plan that resulted in a quick sale and over asking price, all with no open houses and following all covid restrictions.

We can’t say enough good things about Jay. His attention to detail was incredible and he left no stone unturned to find the right buyers for us. He worked tirelessly and the end result was an amazing experience all around. Happy sellers, happy buyers. Thanks Jay for all your hard work and wonderful time spent with us. We have no words to express our gratitude. We would recommend Jay for all of your real estate needs, buying, selling, leasing, there’s no one better. We know that he would work hard for you too!

Jorge & Jenny Lopez

Well, where do I begin…Jay was not only my realtor, he has also become a friend. His expertise and knowledge of the real estate market was an asset, as he sold my home in less than 2 weeks. I knew that I could trust him from our very first meeting. He was always accessible 24/7 to guide me and answer any questions that I had. Selling a home can be very stressful, however Jay made it easy and even fun! 

Thank you, from the bottom of my heart Jay for selling my home and finding the Condo of my dreams! You have, by far exceeded my expectations!

Linda I

I cannot begin to express how amazing Jay was as our realtor! As first time home buyers, it can be very stressful and intimidating especially in today’s market. Jay made it a complete breeze and enjoyable experience. He made sure that we were able to find our perfect first home without going over budget and also, not ever settling for a house that wasn’t the right fit. We looked through many homes, and he was so patient with the process and insuring that we wouldn’t stop looking until the right one came and sure enough, we found our dream house! My partner and myself are so thankful for Jay’s kindness and knowledge throughout the whole process. 10/10 would recommend him to anyone interested in purchasing or selling a home!!

Tori M

We just recently purchased our first home through Jay McLelland at Boldt Realty and cannot say enough fantastic things about our experience!

Jay is wonderful to work with and really cares about his clients as well as the city he lives in. He was so patient and kind with us and made sure that we didn’t settle for just any house in this crazy market. By doing so, we were able to find our dream house and cannot thank him and Boldt enough!

Carlos L

My husband and I are so very grateful that we chose Jay McLelland of Boldt Realty to help us sell our family home of 30 years. His compassion, professionalism and attention to detail are second to none. When my husband suddenly took ill and had to spend 11 days in hospital, Jay made sure that all was moving forward after first checking with us. The fabulous photography,  staging and marketing all led to above asking price in 5 days. in fact, the day my husband got his clean bill of health, we signed the agreement. We are definitely recommending Jay McLelland to all our family, friends and colleagues.

Stella & Mario M

We met Jay while attending his open house and quickly realized Jay was someone we wanted helping us with our search for a home. When we found the home we wanted, Jay quickly lead the way, he did an amazing job negotiating on our behalf. Jay also helped us through the entire process, his services didn’t stop once the sale was completed. He provided contacts for various services, had all of our questions answered and guided us through the entire process. Jay is a great communicator and a pleasure to work with (and apparently he can cook too). Highly recommend!

John & Ingrid

Jay is amazing, he truly cares about his clients. Anytime we ever had a question or didn’t understand something, he would explain it. Jay has went above and beyond for us. So thank you Jay for everything and I will recommend him 10 out of 10 times!!

Val & Jason

Jay is the best! Always helpful and willing to give support with all his contacts.  He answers you back within 5 minutes for even the simplest request. All hours of the day, Jay gives you his guidance and support.  Moving can be very stressful but Jay is there for you from beginning to end. By far the best Realtor out there. Thanks Jay!

Johnny & Hanh